August 3
A Real BBQ

Menu
- Barbecue Sauce Chicken Sandwich [View Recipe]
Quick View
Ingredients
- 1.5 pounds chicken
- oil
- salt & pepper
- 2 medium peppers (rinsed and dried)
- 1 small onion (peeled)
- 1 large bread
- 1 recipe [object Object]
- .75 cup cheese (freshly grated)
- cilantro (cleaned and chopped)
Instructions
We start by preheating our gas grill to medium heat, and preheating the oven to <temp val="350"/>.
We rinse our chicken cutlets and place between two pieces of wax paper. The pieces are inspected and any fat or tough membranes are removed with scissors. Using the flat side of our meat pounder, we flatten the chicken pieces slightly to even out their thicknesses and lessen their cooking times. We place them on a dinner plate and wash our hands well. We pour on a tablespoon of the oil and sprinkle with salt and pepper. We turn with tongs to coat well, then wash the tongs thoroughly.
On another dinner plate, we coat the peppers and onion with another tablespoon of oil.
We grill the chicken and the vegetables on the preheated grill and place the bread in the oven to heat. We have some of the barbecue sauce ready with which we will cook (the rest is reserved for serving) and a pastry brush. The chicken pieces are placed on the grill and, after 3 minutes, we flip each over and brush with some of the sauce to coat. When we flip the pieces over, we are careful to wash the tongs. We are very careful with chicken! After another 2 minutes, we flip again and coat with more sauce. We cook for another minute or two, applying a more generous coating of sauce, and then flip and coat generously again. We allow the breasts to finish cooking until they are cooked through.
Meanwhile, the peppers and onion are turned with clean tongs until softened and browned slightly. When ready, they are placed on a clean plate.
When the bread is heated through, we slice it into nice sandwich chunks and then slice again horizontally. We place some of the cheese inside each to melt in. When the peppers and onions are cooked, we chop them coarsely on a clean cutting board. We also cut the cooked chicken pieces to fit in the sandwiches.
We add the chicken to the cheesy bread along with some of the chopped peppers and onions, some more cheese and a sprinkle of cilantro. We serve with the reserved barbecue sauce (any sauce that is left out by the grill would need to be re-boiled).
- Barbecue Sauce [View Recipe]
Quick View
Ingredients
- 1 cup ketchup
- 2 tablespoons Worcestershire sauce
- 2 tablespoons mustard
- 3 tablespoons molasses
- 2 tablespoons syrup
- 3 tablespoons vinegar
- .5 teaspoon chile powder
- .5 teaspoon chile powder
- .25 teaspoon cumin
- .25 teaspoon cayenne
- 2 cloves garlic
- 1 small onion (peeled)
Instructions
We start in the morning by mixing all of the ingredients, except the garlic and onion, together in a 2 cup measuring cup. Next, we use our garlic press to squeeze the cloves directly into the sauce. The final, and most time consuming, step is the grating of the onion. We use our microplane to grate some of the onion into a bowl. We measure out 1 tablespoon, reserving the rest of the onion for another use. We add the grated onion to the sauce and stir. We have 1 2/3 cup of sauce. It is covered with plastic wrap, and refrigerated.
When we are preparing the dinner, we pour the sauce into a medium sized pan and bring it to a boil over medium heat. We lower the heat, cover partially, and simmer for a few minutes to thicken slightly.
Some of the sauce is reserved in prep bowls to be served with dinner and the remaining is brushed on the food while cooking.
- Grilled Corn
- Rosemary Roasted Potatoes
- Salad with Orange Champagne Vinegar
Luckily, real food was not wasted on only us—Erin came over for dinner. Her visit was something of a re-payment for the Fortunato's the other night, but mostly we were happy to have a visit. Since we know her to be partial to barbecue chicken, we give that a go. In doing so, we violated a cardinal sin of entertaining—never serve something that we have not prepared previously.
Living life on the edge pays off handsomely tonight. The barbecue sauce was fabulous. We might not be the most qualified judges, being city folk and all, but the barbecue sauce was fabulous. After dinner we all piled into the minivan for a quick trip to Moxley's ice cream parlor—just to see if we could get the kids even more excited.